Some of my parishioners think it's goofy that their pastor is a big fan of the television program American Idol.
I admit that I'm an Idol geek, but I think this program is more than a pop culture fad. It is popular because it works at several levels. Here are a few.
It's Mostly Positive
Unlike some competition programs, people are not voted off American Idol. Instead, fans vote for their favorites to remain and the lowest competitors are dropped. In other words, people win based on their merits rather than losing based on cutthroat tactics or maneuvering.
Idol is also generally clean family fare. I'm always a bit bothered by the way it parodies the ignorance and eccentricity of some early-round auditioners, but it's generally an upbeat program nevertheless.
It Challenges People to Grow
One of the delights of this competition is seeing how people to respond to competitive pressure--in other words, how they respond to life. Some are able to accept criticism, learn, and change. Others remain at about the same level throughout the competition. I like seeing people learn and grow in order to excel. That inspires me to do the same.
Idol Models Success
As a former editor, I see parallels between this singing competition and creative arts in general. In order to succeed, contestants must have the same three qualities that make for success in any creative endeavor--originality, passion, and skill. Some complain that the "best singers" don't always win, but that's a lot like life. The smartest people don't always become president and the best preachers don't always build a megachurch.
It takes more than talent to succeed, and Idol reminds me of that.
It Reminds Me to Be Both Candid and Kind
Sometimes the judges are brutally honest, and sometimes contestants need to hear their harsh critique. We don't grow by being told there is no problem when there is.
Generally though, the judges (including Simon) give affirmation for what contestants do right. Everybody needs that too. We don't grow only by being told what we do wrong.
Idol's judges remind me the importance of speaking truth in love, to quote a phrase.
It Teaches How to Lose Gracefully
One of the most interesting moments each week is seeing how contestants respond to the news that they have been dropped from the competition. Some, especially in the early rounds, respond with anger or extreme emotion because they believe their dream has ended.
Others, especially later in the competition, seem to be happy about what they have achieved and grateful for the opportunity. While a bit sad, they realize that their future is in their own hands.
Idol reminds me that a positive outlook leads to a better future.
It's Fun
What? Preachers aren't allowed to have fun? ;-)
What do you think? Are you a fan of American Idol? What do you like about it?
5 comments:
haha! You think justification will make it okay that you are an Idol Geek? As your dear sweet Lydia would say, "Just enjoy it. Don't evaluate it." ...of course, she says that to me too, so maybe I better be quiet. :)
PS This blog entry is a perfect example of why I am so madly in love with you.
PS Where's Kara? I know she's not your favorite judge, but some of us like her.
Just enjoy it. Don't evaluate it.
I LOVE AI. It's the only show I watch (well, besides Monk). What I love is watching some of the contestants grow and flourish from week to week. It reminds me of the "fan into flame" admonition of Paul. There are others, though, who don't grow and do the same ol' thing week after week. Is it a teachability issue? Or lack of talent? Or immaturity? Or lack of effort?
Finally I can also come out the closet and say "I Watch American Idol".
The beginning of the show, although harsh I think also is beneficial in helping saving some people from a lifetime of disappointing, if they want to be professional. I think "EVERYBODY" should be allowed to sing but being asked to be judged then be prepared honest feedback.
I agree with all your observations about the show. Especially this year when they are all so talented in terms of singing and this year seems to really show that how you put yourself into the song is what will connect you with those watching and those voting.
Post a Comment